ChapterFive

M

*The Asian Front     

 

September 10, 2002
Including Field Note Passages From

(Dec. 14, 2001 to Dec. 16, 2001)

 

 

Islamabad,

The Lawless Red Line on the CNN War Map

and

Revenge at Tora Bora

 

Part Three
Revenge

Over the Khyber Pass to
The Outskirts of al-Qaida’s Last Stand

At Tora Bora

 

  

5
Sunday

September 10, 2002

A Lot of Chatter Across the Wires:
A Hot Spot on the Road

 

               “I am so looking forward to September 12.”  [1]

 

                                                                                                                                                     A firefighter whose duty and fate

                                                                                           it was to send his own brother up

                                                                                           the World Trade Center to his death

 

 

                        Today the Breaking News TV just went nuts, like it hadn’t since October 23, 2001 at the height of the Anthrax scare. It started shortly after I’d read the newspaper this morning:

*BREAKING NEWS
        9:50 a.m.

 

* Police investigating Noelle Bush, the Governor of Florida , Jeb Bush’s daughter, for possession of a controlled substance while serving a drug sentence at a drug rehabilitation center. Crack cocaine was reportedly found in Bush’s rehab room.” [2]

            Then I was on the telephone with Janet at 10:45 a.m., and she told me that she’d just gotten off the telephone with a colleague who was at that moment sitting on a jetliner taxiing on the runway for takeoff at Miami International Airport in Florida. She reported to me that he called her up to ask her if she’d ever been to the Miami airport, and she told him she had and that she remembered it as, “A crazy and chaotic place choked with frenzied hordes.” He reported to her that the jetliner he was on (on this edgy anniversary eve --- the first second Tuesday in September since September 11) was nearly empty, and that the airport had been so quiet that he chose the word “still” to describe it.
           
“It’s spooky,” Janet reported him telling her, “and I’m a little bit concerned...” ---the video horror clips on the 24-hour CNN Breaking News Box probably piercing through his brain like a bullet.

            I got off the phone, and was returning to my research in front of the 24-hour CNN Breaking News Box when I heard the CNN Breaking News Jingle again.

*BREAKING NEWS
       10:49 a.m.

 

* The US government has just raised the level of concern on the terror alert scale from “Elevated Risk” to “High Risk.” “There’s a lot of chatter on the wires,” was all the TV could get the government to tell it so far ...

            Probably just another scare. Hopefully it won’t elevate itself into attack status by events, but there’s been a hundred scares or more since this whole mess started, so chances are slim it’ll turn out to be important. Terror scares are a big new part of this whole new world. Getting a scare over the news box and then later on -- after nothing happens aside from exposing the scare as a precautionary false alarm -- there’s a moment of relief and then life goes on ...

*BREAKING NEWS
        11:35 a.m.

 

* F-16 fighter jets scrambled to escort a small plane to a landing in Charlotte, North Carolina due to a security concern. The plane was reportedly registered in Egypt.

            Another scare. One of those airplane scares we’ve gotten accustomed to over the last year when fighter jets escort an airplane to a precautionary landing where everything usually turns out OK --- just someone in authority not willing to take a single chance, willing instead to err on the side of safety. Except for that one time at the end of last year when the Christmas Shoe Bomber turned out to be al-Qaida’s last and best scraggly shot at raining on the American Coalition’s Tora Bora parade and on everyone else’s holiday season.

*BREAKING NEWS
         12:35 p.m.

 

            * Attorney General John Ashcroft announced that Vice President Dick Chaney had been moved to an undisclosed location and he read aloud the terror alert warning he issued this morning raising the level of concern from “Elevated Risk” to “High Risk” calling it, “A sobering warning.”

The Ashcroft statement:

 

      The United States government has concluded --- based on analysis and specific intelligence of possible attacks on US interests overseas --- to call government, law enforcement and citizens, both at home and overseas, to a heightened state of alert.

 

After conferring with the Homeland Security Council, the recommendation has been made to increase the national threat level currently classified at ‘elevated risk’ to ‘high risk.’ The president has accepted this recommendation.

 

The US intelligence community has received information based on debriefings of a senior al-Qaida operative of possible terrorist attacks timed to coincide with the anniversary of the September 11 attacks on US facilities. These cells have been accumulating explosives since approximately January of 2002 this year in preparation for these attacks.

 

The US intelligence community has concluded that the most likely targets of al-Qaida attacks are the transportation and energy sectors and facilities for gatherings that would be recognized worldwide as symbols of American power or security. Examples of such symbols are US military facilities, US embassies and national monuments.”

            After that round of alerts, CNN kept the Breaking News headline up on the screen from the time it first came on, all the way through the evening --- for more than 12 straight hours.

 

 

*We Still Love This Park

                       In between all that 24-hour CNN Breaking News, the TV showed me 64 video horror clips today (22 of jets hitting, 11 of people jumping, 31 of buildings collapsing), and I read a poignant article in the special September 11 anniversary edition of Newsweek Magazine. About how a family’s trauma continues --- a very sad story about how when their murdered father’s car was finally towed back home and when the kids saw it in the driveway, how they started screaming: “Daddy’s home!! Daddy’s home!!”

            It all made me pessimistic, and I wondered whether I should cancel my root canal appointment scheduled for tomorrow --- just in case something bad happens on TV on this September 11. And that made me laugh --- pondering war jets being deployed all over the sky and artillery being moved all over the Washington DC battlefront because everyone’s scared of the terrorists --- while here I sit on the Kansas homefront frightened that I’ll miss it all on TV while undergoing dental surgery.

            But then a little later on while I was flipping through my portfolio from 1996, I ran across that streetphoto I made outside Centennial Olympic Park in Atlanta . Made in the hour the park reopened after the tragic terrorist bomb that exploded there during the Summer Olympics of 1996 closed it down for three days. I was in Atlanta to watch Nigeria win the gold medal in soccer and to watch Dan O’Brien win the Gold in the decathlon. And especially to watch Michael Johnson melt the 200-meter world record --- running the event in 19.32 and breaking the old sprint standard by a whopping .34-of-a-second. “The sports moment of the decade,” according to some TV sports pundits.

            The bomb exploded three days before I got to Atlanta , killing one and injuring 111 and the park had been closed down while police gathered evidence, while Olympic officials instituted heightened security, and while the family buried its dead. But when the park reopened to the public on the day I made that picture, instead of staying away--- people flocked to the place. To thumb their noses at terrorism, no matter how dangerous it might have been to stroll around Olympic Park ground zero. Still under threat of attack from the still-unknown bomber.

            I looked at that streetphoto portrait I’d made of that moment. Of a newspaper vendor standing in the middle of a crowded sidewalk selling copies of an Atlanta Journal-Constitution extra (Breaking News) edition, blaring the banner nose-thumbing headline with an hour-old photo of the re-opening already printed on the front page that read:

            We Still Love This Park!

 

So I decided, despite my misgivings, that I’d show up at the dentist tomorrow anyway --- just to show the terrorists still out there what I’m made of ...

            Then tonight I watched a Public Broadcasting System documentary about the historical highlights of last year’s terror turmoil, and it covered the Battle of Tora Bora.” It was the first time I’d seen a documentary description about what happened last year. The first of a slew of historical films that will haunt us for the rest of our lives on the History Channel. It characterized the battle as a ground war involving, “Several different Afghan Alliance factions who rushed the White Mountains independently after several days of American Coalition bombing and who were ineffective (fumbling) at first, but who became more effective as days passed and as the bombing from the Coalition intensified.”

            The program talked about how the net was tightened around the terrorist cave complex and how one Alliance warlord tried unsuccessfully to negotiate with the terrorists. About how relentless US air strikes continued nevertheless through the negotiations and about how there had been numerous civilian casualties on the outskirts of the battlefield. Characterizing the unintended deaths as, “The direct result of legitimate military targets being purposely hidden among innocents.” Admitting that, “conscious choices were made to take out those targets and risk those civilian lives.” The documentary said it found that there had been, About 400 documented al-Qaida deaths at Tora Bora” and that there “had probably been many more unknown dead,” buried in caves or disintegrated beyond recognition in explosions. And the program reported that, “60 Taliban and al-Qaida prisoners had been taken at Tora Bora,” but that, “Large numbers had slipped across the border into (and maybe through) the Tribal Areas of Pakistan.”

            The program reported that prisoners told captors that, “Osama bin Laden had been at Tora Bora, gave a speech, had some tea, and then disappeared  back into the White Mountains ...”

            And there I’d been.

            Underneath those bombers of Tora Bora.

            Late last fall, for about 75 minutes at it’s penultimate moment, I made it to only a couple of dozen miles away or so from the bombing and within hazy sight of the eastern White Mountain foothills battlefield. To some of the nearest streets to and in the same combat airspace as Tora Bora on the outskirts of World War III.

 

 

~

December 14, 2001

Peshawar Pakistan to the Tora Bora Sky View

 

 

We’ll Either Bring Them to Justice

or We’ll Bring Justice to Them

 

Headline News*[3]

Early Edition

*    Relentless American Bombing at Tora Bora on Friday and Saturday

*    US Special op Forces Now Engaged in Direct Combat With Al Qaeda:

            Two US special operations forces were wounded today at Tora Bora ... Afghan tribal
    forces
operating with a few dozen US commandos and supported by American air power,
   are closing in from the north, and Pakistan army troops stand in al- Qaeda’s way to the
   south and west... Airforce U-2s and unmanned Global Hawk surveillance planes are
   scanning mountain passes to the east and west of Tora Bora.”

*    US Narrowing OBL Options for Escape From Tora Bora

             But Pentagon reluctant to embrace notion that Osama bin Laden has been surrounded.”

*    US Marines Block Roads Around Kandahar Searching For Mohammed Omar And Others

*    Attack on Indian Parliament Has Everyone on Edge:

                  India Blaming Pakistan

            The suicide attack on the Indian parliament yesterday killed 12 and injured 70. India says
     the
suicide attack was the work of Islamic militants opposed to India in Kashmir and he
    pointed a finger at Pakistan .”

 

 

*The Khyber Pass:
    A S
toried Backwater

                       I woke up this morning before sunrise and after catching up on the latest news on the CNN Breaking News Box --- about the India Parliament attack and about what was going on over at Tora Bora --- I reviewed the description of the Khyber Pass I’d highlighted in my travel guidebook. Just in case I get to go there today. It called the place “dangerous” and “uninviting” but said it possessed throughout the ages, “A romantic notion of passages of civilizations through it or blocked by it.”

 

            Today I passed back into Afghanistan through the Khyber Pass where (as a regular pissed-off American -- white with foam) I’d wanted to get to since September 11. Only about four or five miles inside, I suppose. But I had a dozen F-18 and F-14 fighter-jet sightings while I was there as they ripped the sky on their way in and out of the al-Qaida Tora Bora cave complex area in the nearby Afghan White Mountains in the Spinghar Range. I heard the roar of too many B-52 and B-1 bombers to keep track of and I saw the exhaust streaming behind some of them in the distance as they sped in for the kill. Once I saw what I took to be a B-1 bomber take a low-level swipe at the battlefront. And several times fighter jets flew back and forth across my sky from bombardments and the like on what the CNN Breaking News Box told me later when I got back to my Peshawar hotel was the Al-Qaida Last Stand at Tora Bora. Powerful, relentless, bloodthirsty bombing. Crushing Osama bin Laden’s last surviving organized pack of cronies and delivering to them their due justice.

            I and two Spanish freelance journalists --- who I never really got to know but who were kind enough to offer me a lift on their way to Jalalabad --- were turned around by machine gun-toting Afghani tribal escorts because

a new alert for journalists had been issued on our route due to another attempted attack on a media caravan halfway between Jalalabad and Kabul . Of course, if the Spaniards could come up with another --- say $500 or so --- then the hired guns told them they could, “Absolutely guarantee your safe arrival in Jalalabad”  by adding their weight to the two guns the Spanish had already been forced to hire for $150 apiece at the border.

            Instead, we turned back to Peshawar with little information and hardly an opportunity to take pictures of anything, the Spaniards planning to wait the four or five days they thought it would take them to wire for more bribe money and to outlast the complications the al-Qaida and Taliban flight from Tora Bora was causing them on that road. Making the historically hazardous route to Jalalabad an even more chaotic and unstable place in more turmoil than it typically is. As the desperate terrorists head our way and pass by us and the waiting Pakistan army. Like happened to me and my friends yesterday at the refugee camp school on the border. Seeking sanctuary as the American Coalition air forces relentlessly pound the holdouts in their caves and search for retreating hot spots on the sides of the roads to target. Such as the three of us, our driver-guide, and our crew of eight Pashtun tribal guards probably appeared at that time from the eye in the sky.

 

            It was an edgy situation, and I wasn’t comfortable with the hot spot issue. But there I found myself with time to reflect at a peanut-gallery view of the historic rout. And as I stood there watching those war jets dart about the sky, I became eerily satisfied --- surrealistically becalmed and content. Suddenly at peace with myself for the first time in three months and at peace with where I’d ended up getting to on this streetphoto trip. Standing there watching a 90-degree slice of the air war from the cheap seats, I became resigned to the fact that I wasn’t going to be able to afford access to or otherwise get lucky enough to weasel a shoot on either the streets of Kabul or now on the streets of Jalalabad either. But I know what I’m seeing while I’m seeing it --- and I was truly satisfied with my right place at the right time fortune.

            Frighteningly satisfied and grateful.

            For getting over the Khyber Pass to that hot spot on the side of the road on the most vicious day of bombing at the Tora Bora rout and for getting the opportunity to watch from so close up and so first hand this historic act of civilized retribution --- the Al-Qaida Last Stand.

 

*Borrowed Access:

Right Place -- Right Time

 

085-OBL Poster For Sale.jpg (174804 bytes)

 

The Streets of Peshawar

 

 

                        I met the two Spanish freelance journalists late on Wednesday afternoon at the nearby Green’s Saddar Bazaar Hotel just down the street from my place while I was out beating around the streets taking streetphotos and trying to get a grip on the mindset of the people I was meeting and studying with my cameras. Green’s Hotel was a place that costs $25 per night and which provided tenants a much more formidable machine- gun guard at its door then the raggedy man guarding my raggedy hotel down the street at Khani’s. The freelancers were slumming it down here at 2000 rupees a night, but neither would stoop to the 500-rupee place I slept in, and they told me so. It was a brief meeting, as they were on the fly to arrange tribal papers for the passage of their vehicle and their driver-guide over the Khyber Pass, but they were impressed with my method and my poise and agreed if we had the chance to hook up that they might have enough spare room in their taxi-van to allow me to accompany them as far as Jalalabad, perhaps on Friday afternoon.

            I had a big day Thursday in and out of Afghanistan at the refugee camps with Shahid and his wife, getting the streetphotos I’d flown here to get.

After getting back from the camps I crashed hard with my flu during the late afternoon, but even after oversleeping I found I hadn’t missed the Spanish journalists and we met again briefly in the lobby of Green’s Hotel on Thursday evening and made a date to head west on Friday afternoon. I was so stoked by the news that I may have weaseled a ride, that I ignored the fact that I might be arraigning a ride too far into harms way and I spent two hours photographing Saddar Bazaar as the sun went down --- ending up getting my best shot of the extreme night-time mood of Peshawar.

            It was of several angry Taliban cheerleaders as they menaced me out on the street.

            The incident was short but scary.

 

 

 

            Three of them got in my way on the sidewalk, so I used my camera as a shield, and pulled it up to my eye and made a streetphoto of them menacing an American and claiming victory for the Taliban. That made them laugh for a moment and as they were giggling to each other I slipped past them and walked away toward a more crowded alley without ever looking back or responding to their catcalls --- taunts I only understood in abstract.
 

 


 

 

            And then after a long night divided between sleep, writing, and watching TV, I spent this morning photographing Saddar Bazaar in a festive end-of-Ramadan Juma’h (holy Friday) holiday mood.

 

Pak. Peshawar Vest Salesman.jpg (99515 bytes)

 

087i-Afghan Woman Begging copy.jpg (119384 bytes)

 

087h-Peshawar LadderScape.jpg (215979 bytes)

 

Pak. At the Movies.jpg (406582 bytes)

 

Peshawar Street Kitchen.jpg (157717 bytes)

 


At one point I scared myself by straying into a Friday noon prayer session on the streets. A dangerous time when the streets close down to motor traffic and are blocked in many places by huge chanting prayer groups and when afterward --- depending on what they hear that day from the mullah --- political tensions build up to the burning of American flags. I’d have liked to have photographed an after-prayer flag burning (capturing more of the anger and extremism I think I may have captured last night in the bazaar), but before prayers were over I’d already hooked up with the freelancers and in a matter of five minutes notice we were off on our little drive to the west.

We drove as madly as the freelancer’s driver-guide dared (scary fast) and everyone in the SUV-like taxi-van seemed anxious, including the hired machine-gun-toting “escort” we’d been forced (the Spanish had been forced) to hire for $175 to guide us through the 45-mile trip to the border. We sped past smarmy frontier trading posts and up the Khyber Pass ...

            The Khyber Pass is remarkably unimpressive as a mountain pass. Brown and littered and teeming at places with smarmy tribal (smuggler) outposts; an old fort here, an abandoned rail line over there. A neglected building at the border that looked like it had once either been an army barracks or maybe a hotel or tourist welcome center. Switchback climbs and descents with mostly un-magnificent broad, brown, and baron views that only closed in on the road occasionally. Places I was under the order of the gun not to film.

            As we sped and bumped along past another outpost our driver told us was called either Smuggler’s Market or The Gun and Poppy Bazaar, I got the feeling our un-smiling hired guide (sitting next to me on the back seat) was guarding his tribe from us more than he was guarding us from bandits, the Taliban, or al-Qaida. Because on that one occasion when I did reach around to get my cameras and to test the guard’s no photos resolve, he wagged the tip of the mussel of his Kalashnikov (which was pointed straight up toward the roof of the truck) back and forth at me, and shook his head no as well.

            The border itself was more passive and uncluttered with people than it had been when I first saw media clips of it on the CNN News Box two or three weeks ago while I was still in Lawrence. Since most of the new refugees had already headed east and south ahead of the Tora Bora campaign. And since the busloads and mass caravans of journalists headed west just before the area was made the front lines by the retreating Taliban and al-Qaida forces and by the advancing Pakistan Army, American Marines, and anti-Taliban Alliance ground forces.

            All our papers and passports and permits were in order. And after a few bribes paid for by the more-and-more cash-strapped freelancers and an invitation by Pakistani soldiers to continue (but only after the Spanish hired an additional set of armed Afghani-sanctioned tribal guns) we drove about eight or nine kilometers into Afghanistan to the first checkpoint. A parked Toyota pickup truck loaded down with six kames-garbed machine-gun-toting Afghani tribal forces.

            We were told we’d be able to use our cameras at the second checkpoint, but as it turned out on this day, we were never to see a second checkpoint. Only the first. The tribal fighters told us that the road was closed because of its proximity to the conflict in the adjacent White Mountains. They mentioned the uncertainty, “Even where we stand now,” of running into desperate Taliban fighters or a group of foreign terrorists trying to flee to Pakistan. And they indicated that there might have been some trouble up ahead on the road this morning, a trouble they said they were not at liberty to discuss with us. They did indicate to the Spanish that if they had a lot more cash than the Spanish had, that they would have taken the chance of smuggling us through to the second checkpoint. But the Spanish had almost run out of their budgeted bribe money and certainly didn’t have near the gunmen’s asking price in their pockets for just another ten-kilometer guarantee to the next checkpoint (and probable next passage fee negotiation as well).

            Unlike the depressed United Nations airfare to Kabul that I found back in Islamabad (was $4800 -- now $2400), the cost of travel around here had risen considerably since the big-buck corporate journalism boys and girls started blowing through here a couple of weeks ago with their wads of network cash.

            During the hour and a quarter of debate between the freelancers and the gunmen (broken Spanish, broken English, a lot of primitive hand signals, and a few drawn maps of the Tora Bora combat zone in the road sand that I’d have loved to have photographed if permitted,) I sat under the air theater and I passively watched American Coalition jets and bombers zipping at and rumbling over the White Mountains past the closest White Mountain ridges just to our southwest and watching the fighter jets re-forming right above us and even behind us for further attacks. The fighting this afternoon (as I understood later from TV reports) was mostly centered on the ridges in between the hazy mountain foothills off in the distance that screened our view, and we could neither see the exploding bombs nor hear the sound of the bombs exploding under the waves of bombers roaring overhead. The bombs probably falling at least a couple of dozen miles (perhaps a horizon or two) away, but the frantic air theater was happening all around and directly above our heads.

            Leftover jet contrails littering the sky all around us.

            And I’ll be damned if it didn’t feel good to be there!

            Just a regular global-minded American artist, chain-smoking Marlboro cigarettes and watching the civilized world-supported American forces bomb the soul-less bastards who committed September 11 into next week. World-class louts who manipulated the insane and weak and who’d hijack an entire religion, an entire peace-loving world. Who ran civilian jet airplanes into civilian buildings just because they could. Who’d killed thousands of innocent global citizens and who now are principally culpable for nearly 4000 Afghani civilian deaths as well. Either before the American Coalition started dropping bombs on them while the extremists went medieval on the people, or after America began fighting back against the kind of cowards who’d use women and children as human shields during battle. All just to show us how large they viewed the value of their own existence, their own stinking manhood.

            And I sat there, and I leaned against the bumper of that taxi-van, thumbing my nose at that goddamn shrinking manhood. Accidentally-on-purpose being at this place at this time and thumbing my nose at the terror. Smiling at the thought of their emasculating defeat and the carnage being done to them over that ridge --- --- --- right over there where those two fighter jets just went in ...

            It looks like I won’t get the chance to kill him myself,” I thought, “but the games must go on ...”

            The CNN Breaking News Box reports that I watched after getting back to my hotel room combined with my small eye-witness slice of the air war left me feeling as though I’d finally caught up to September 11. Watching the fighter jets and hearing the thundering bombers roaring over the red line on the CNN War Map at the outskirts of the battle, I’d finally caught up to the instant I saw that second jetliner smash into the World Trade Center in New York at 3:03 p.m. in Amsterdam on September 11, when I knew I’d be coming to this war. I’d caught up to and overcome the grip of helplessness and sorrow I’d suffered since then. I’d caught up to and overcome the perplexed state that the tragedy had left crying inside of me.

            It still wasn’t September 12th for me yet -- but it was close ...

            For an hour and a quarter I was right in the middle of the anvil in the hammer-and-anvil maneuver on the red line on the 24-hour CNN Breaking News Box War Map. And in those 75 minutes, I got what Janet got at the Eiffel Tower in Paris a week after the September 11 attack. I’d succeeded in reaching the Zen of my own personal nose-thumbing expectations. After three lousy months of watching the distress on the CNN Breaking News Box, I’d come to a therapeutic understanding of my own uncivilized bloodlust capabilities in light of years spent hounding those who found such bloodthirst an acceptable way of life (in light of less-acceptable, more obscene circumstances) to declare unnecessary war in my name. It occurred to me then that it was time --- watching the jets zip by and the bombers bomb away --- to begin suppressing the horrible events of September 11. To begin drying up all the tears of the months gone by since. To stop worrying so much and to just start feeling comfortable with the hypocrisies of the polar notions of peace and self-defense and in this case to fight evil with evil for the sake of civilization and even for the sake of pacifism --- no matter how obscene that sounds.

            The logic of self-defense eludes the pacifist ideal, I’d heard a TV commentator say. But today I found the logic of pacifism eluding the self-defense ideal.

            I was at peace.

            I’d thumbed my nose at terrorism. At those evil bastards who’d ruined what I saw as a pretty good post-Cold War era of peace and prosperity and who’d killed some of the finest people from 90 countries on Earth because they felt inferior and trapped inside vacuums of mostly their own conjuring. I felt, there on that Afghan road, that I’d duly honored the flag and the president of the United States and the mayor of New York City and all those public service announcements I’d heard on the CNN homefront Breaking News Box all fall. The appeals that kept urging me to pitch in on the war effort by going about my normal life. Who kept encouraging me to thumb my nose at the terrorists by not letting their crime stop me from going about my normal life. I followed that advice, and I came out here to practice street photography at the edge of the fury on streets in turmoil. And in that time on these roadways in Pakistan and Afghanistan, I’ve succeeded in doing my part to the best of my abilities.

            As happens, and in spite of my own reservations, I’d ended up in harms way to get this far. But the Spanish had run out of both money and arguments with our tribal handlers, and we were also about to run out of time for getting to a locked room in either Jalalabad or Peshawar by sundown. So we turned the taxi-van around and headed back over the border and over the brown Khyber Pass and back down to our hotels at Saddar Bazaar in Peshawar.

            Past the Pakistan Army searching for fleeing al-Qaida. Past the Pushtun tribal force searching for customers. Past the refugees and otherwise displaced by the war. And past the merchants selling guns, drugs, and Osama bin Laden tribute T-shirts at the smuggler bazaars. Back to my cigarette-burns-in-the-carpet/ cold-water room for the night in the edgy and increasingly more-defeated and more-remorseful Saddar Bazaar in Peshawar.

            Made to feel like a liberator yesterday in the Afghan refugee camps and made to feel like a winner today while watching the air war on the Khyber Pass.

            Feeling relatively balanced for the first time since that awful Amsterdam afternoon on September 11, 2001.

            Feeling like the calendar had finally flipped from September 11 to December 14...

            Feeling like a goddamn bunker-busting daisy-cutter bomb on the Fourth of July ...

 

 

*REVENGE

    Inform Them of an Excruciating Pain

 

 

 

            “As for those who reject the signs of God and kill prophets, alienated from truth, and kill those who call for justice for the people, inform them of an excruciating pain. They are those whose works are futile in this world and the hereafter; and they have no helpers or protectors.”                                                                                                                                                                                                 the Quran

 

 

                        Getting myself under the Tora Bora air war --- especially as close as I got today --- wasn’t bittersweet. It should have been bittersweet, I suppose, but bittersweet just didn’t turn out to be the right way to put it, because suddenly, I wasn’t bitter any more. Making my impressions of an extraordinary moment in a rarefied place full of people in flux. Caught between civility and barbarism, religion and reality, good and evil. It was extremely sweet, what happened to me today, because my calendar had finally and surprisingly turned from September 11 to December 14. Sweet because I’d been given the opportunity through fate and determination to watch thousands of innocent global lives (souls disturbed by means beyond their control) addressed. Debts settled from Kenya and Tanzania, from New York City and Washington DC. And especially somehow for me from that farm field in Pennsylvania.

            I conjured up all the lowlights of my own suffering: the immediate and frighteningly primitive boiling rages I endured in Amsterdam and on returning to Kansas from Ground Zero; being terrified and distressed and confounded by it all; remembering September 11 and how I didn’t know how to react because up until that time, “I always knew what to do next;” that indescribably powerless feeling of panic and loss I had, how I had to hold my head up in my hands during the attack to force myself to keep watching the agonizing terror up on the television screen --- and to stop my head from shaking back and forth.

            I thought about that American woman at the Down Under Coffeeshop who put her three fingers up to her lips after the north World Trade Center tower collapsed, the two streams of tears leading from her sad unbelieving eyes to the three fingers stuck in shock on her shivering lips. That terrible unbelieving pose that became a monumental image for me, that I had no heart at the time to bother capturing on film.

And I remembered those haunting souls of September 11 that I witnessed getting their bad news in the rain at that green sidewalk telephone tree behind Dam Square in Amsterdam. That poor screaming woman thrashing about in the puddles while her mate struggled to grasp the meaning of his whole new world.

            All the death and horror avenged --- to a degree.

            Self-defense, liberation, and vengeance played out in the Afghan mountains at the red line on the 24-hour CNN Breaking News Box War Map.

            And it should have all been so confusing. Because the same obscene human endeavor of war that gave me post-traumatic shock syndrome and those aggravating anxiety hives twenty years before in Central America during the Cold War --- today somehow made me feel whole again. There’s no proper way to accurately commemorate a thing like that, I suppose --- how I felt so light and buoyant and so satisfied under that brutal air war today. A lot of words can go into describing what I saw and how I felt --- all just avoiding the awful truth ...

            Because the right word for what happened to me today isn’t “bittersweet.” The right word wasn’t even part of my lexicon until three months and three days ago. An unspeakable word that’s left a translucent slash across my soul.

            To know as well as I now know --- the essence of the word revenge.

 

            REVENGE!

 

            The un-apologetic satisfaction of appreciating the primal bloodlust of revenge commonly felt (as September 11 had taught us) by those wronged by evil so despicable as to be unforgivable. So inhumane as to deserve neither compassion nor even a single lick of a good man’s mercy.

            I’ve spent a lifetime suppressing my ability to work myself up to the point of bloodlust, and the ability or passion to seek revenge. Keeping those ugly and hateful instincts at arms length and hoping any thoughts of them rising would dissolve from my mind. But goddamit --- I truly do hate those bastards who blasted their airplane bombs into my life. And so I sat there under their Tora Bora dead end stand for a while this afternoon, glad they were in their final hours of rampage in Afghanistan and in this world. Now splintered and scattered to the winds all around me. Their anarchy perhaps about to give way to better rather than worse ...

            I sat on the bumper of that taxi-van today on the outskirts of World War III disturbingly becalmed. Arms folded, facing the air war, thrilled to be at that awful place at that awful time. Disturbingly becalmed yet unrepentantly thrilled to be attending the deaths of whichever wicked terrorists were in those Tora Bora caves today.

            An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind.

            I’ve always believed that.

            Yet now I find myself knocked off-center of that ideal, at least for the time being. Because of the circumstances of this affair, I didn’t have the time Gandhi had to be so patient. Proving again, I suppose, that I’m just a regular imperfect American guy. But I’ve suffered and I’ve been burdened with tyranny and homicide, and this afternoon I was blind in my pain and my rage.

            In fact I’m proud to say that I carried a postcard with me today in the bottom of my camera bag that I bought from a vendor at Ground Zero the week before last. Of the north wall of the north tower of the World Trade Center burning and of the south tower being struck and exploding into flames at 9:03 a.m. (ET) on September 11.

            I was as bloodthirsty as all-get-out today, but it’s not just me.

            From what I’ve been hearing on the CNN Breaking News Box, an awful lot of bombs hit terrorist caves today (a few miles up the road from my hot spot) with I Y New York bumper stickers attached to them.

            We need safety and security --- --- --- and we need it now!

            The Western world and every other civilized being on the planet needs immediate peace of mind from this thing. Needs to know that the criminals capable of the September 11-magnitude attack against the world are now on the run and dying in caves rather than figuring out how best to use whatever they’ve got left in their arsenal against the civilized world. Perhaps biological or nuclear attacks. Or worse.

            Worse?

            A person with a sound mind has got to figure that the zealots --- after what happened in September --- are capable of inflicting whatever might be worse. They attack innocent people without mercy and with crazed criminal lust and with no regard for their own lives.

            What could be worse than that?

            We needed revenge today, and we’ll still need revenge tomorrow, when sometime down the road --- a month, a year, or two years from now --- when the splinters of the al-Qaida and Taliban who escaped past me this week on the streets of the red line on the 24-hour CNN Breaking News Box War Map regroup to do more harm.

            No remorse.

            No guilt.

            No apologies.

            We need revenge right now more than we need sanctity for our method of revenge and more than we need forgiveness for our weaknesses. Because today the civilized world and I both got our pound of flesh at a place called the Tora Bora terrorist cave complex inside the bloody lawless tribal region of the Peshawar/Kandahar/Jalalabad triangle.

 

            And all good rumors aside --- I was there to make sure ...

  

 

*Tora Bora Bystander:

      Finding Happiness in the Ooze of a Developing Global Muck ...

 

                         When I got under the warplanes of Tora Bora and over the red-line CNN War Map border, I felt as though I’d finally reached a point in my whole new world where optimism was possible. Where looking forward again was an option.

            Thumbing my nose at terror today with the sight and sound and feel and smell and taste of the war all around me. And with the spit and bluster and Kalashnikov stares of radical Islam in my face. Two weeks in Peshawar and Islamabad and Rawalpindi street bazaars, finally feeling as if I’d caught up and in many ways got ahead of the shock of this whole thing ...

            I was like most everyone else in America. Just like most every other civilized person on this planet --- which it turns out includes just about everyone on Earth except a twisted few. And like all of us, I’ve been in shock. I’ve been perplexed by the magnitude of it all and I’ve felt helpless watching it all happen on the CNN Breaking News Box.

            Helpless --- as planes crashed into buildings.

            Helpless --- as terrified people called home to say good-bye.

            Helpless --- as people jumped to their deaths rather than be engulfed in the flames or crushed to the ground with the building.

            We were all shocked, and afraid, and perplexed, and helpless. We were all in excruciating pain. This was insanity, what was happening up on our CNN Breaking News Boxes, and the implications terrified us all. But because I’d spent a lifetime building an alternative art career with perks that sanction working with history (even dangerous history) in order to capture intriguing human street stories, I (unlike most) had the license to get myself access to the Northwest Frontier Province of Pakistan and into eastern Afghanistan and near the White Mountains of the Tora Bora cave complex battlefield. In order (as it turned out) to get in touch with and catch up to my own September 11 psychosis.

            Artistic, historic, and therapeutic it was ...

            Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, Amen. Because I didn’t feel manipulated by my flag today ( as was my typical pre-September 11 condition), and for a change I even felt a little bit proud.

            It wasn’t business, it was personal...

            To hear the roar, and to watch the B-52 and B-1 bombing runs and the slicing through the air of fighter jets protecting my human right to be there avenging my pain.

            I’d caught up with September 11.

            Simultaneously vulnerable yet feeling invincible under the roar of the bombers of Peshawar and the Battle of Tora Bora, I finally found myself adequately prepared for year 2002. Ready to go on with the rest of my recovery now.

            Caught up.

            Ready to forgive myself for my bloodlust, for wishing so many people horrible death and for enjoying myself more than I had since before that afternoon of September 11 in Amsterdam, before watching the slaughter on TV. A couple of Baileys on ice and some beers, a stroll down Huidenstraat toward the Jardaan garden and pub district, an unexpected pit stop at a down under bar called the Down Under. And then all at once the announcer on the CNN Breaking News Box told me that:  

 

            “An airplane hit the north tower of the World Trade Center seven minutes ago. It was reported to have been a light aircraft...”

 

            And then a few minutes later the second jet exploded along with all its implications. First confusion. Then fear and anger. Then resolve. And now for me it’s all ended up in un-remorseful bloodlust revenge. For me it had been 3:03 p.m. in Amsterdam  for 13 weeks and three days.

            On September 11 I’d spouted off to that international bar crowd in Amsterdam about how this act of war would split the world into civilized and uncivilized camps and evolve quickly into a splintering of the terrorist’s resistance by the civilized and a ferreting out of their caves in Afghanistan by the brave as a first step in the new global war against terrorism. And in the past four days I’ve caught up to that story. Getting myself under the coalition air forces bombing the snot out of the cowards and murderers just over the hill a couple of dozen miles away from me. The last effectively organized stand of al-Qaida and Taliban terrorists dying in their cave complexes in the White Mountains.

            I recalled the fellow stranded yank I met in Amsterdam on the day after the attack on America. The guy at Cafe Chaos who told me, “I’m too old or I’d like to go over there and help get those bastards. I’d sign up for another tour right now if I still could. I’d like to be there when they get him ...”

 

            Well, for all the world, it felt like I’d done just that. Been there when they got him...

            I felt good about the rage I’d carried around with me for those months and about how I’d come to terms with that rage, using my professional reputation for imbedding myself on historic streets at historic times and taking art walks through dangerous bazaars in order to get close enough to make as dynamic street photography of it in it’s time as possible. In order to smell the story, to be caught up in the story. To come to the red line on the CNN Breaking News Box War Map, to Peshawar, and to Tora Bora with my streetphoto cameras and with my white foaming rage. And with a mental health agenda of catching up to my pain. To overtake the terror by making a meaningful artwork or two deep inside the zone I know of as: Getting Ahead of the News.

            Getting ahead of the news today (I had a slice of the story before they could tell me all about it on the TV) and getting revenge as well. A regular American fly on a wilting Islamic jihad wall, expressing himself and recovering his clock from the rubble of the ruin ...

 

   Headline News*
 L
ate Edition
[4]

        *    Furious Air Campaign Today Over Tora Bora

        *    NY Times --- Tora Bora

                      AC-130s sent streams of fire today at al-Qaida diehards on the sides of a mountain ridge and dropped spotter flares onto the target. Then an air strike seemed to set the very hills on fire, perhaps by striking an enemy weapons depot. Trees were splintered into fragments, small bits of clothing in the aftermath spread about like confetti and the metal remains of cluster bombs littered the ground. Before the Afghanis left the Tora Bora battlefield site for the night they collected trucks full of the splintered trees to use as firewood.”

        *    NY Times --- Tora Bora

                       “Even as American forces and their Afghan allies close in on al-Qaida fighters in the mountains here, the forbidding terrain and the stubbornness of some of the foreign followers of Osama bin  Laden are making the struggle for Tora Bora the most complex battle of the war...not to capture a place, but to capture or kill up to 1000 hardened fighters in one of the country’s most rugged mountain terrains.”

        *    “Al- Qaida is finished,” crowed Afghan commander Hazrat Ali from his battlefield perch below the caves on Friday afternoon.  “The Arab fighters,” he insisted, “were prepared to surrender, and the Chechen fighters were determined to fight on. But now they are surrounded.”

        *    About 40 miles east of Tora Bora lies Pakistan’s Tirah Valley, a semi-autonomous tribal belt only nominally under government control. Established in the late 19th century by the British as a buffer zone between Afghanistan and British India. Once fugitives get into Pakistan, locals report, ‘They will find broad pockets of sympathy throughout the province of the Northwest Frontier.’”

        *    Musician Neil Young said today that he’s in support of tough measures against the September 11 terrorists...”

 

 

~

December 15, 2001

Peshawar, Pakistan

 

After Revenge: Bitter Pill

 

 

                        I woke up at 3:20 a.m. this morning after getting about four hours of mean and disturbing sleep. The wall of traffic noise (and the horn symphony outside my window) was continuous on Friday night. But when I crashed, I did so easily. Out of shaky fatigue from my last two big days out and because after nearly two weeks I’d gotten used to the traffic noise like a camper gets used to sleeping next to falling water in the outback. After a couple of workweeks now, the clamor of Pakistani commerce isn’t keeping me awake any longer, but instead is putting me to sleep with its flow. What I used to refer to as the, “goddam motorcycle rickshaws,” and the, “goddam horn blowing” from anything moving with a horn to blow, and the, “goddam vendors” with all their goddam shouted come-ons --- has turned for me the past several days into a babbling brook.

            I’d taken yet another dose of Contact 12-hour Cold and Flu at 8:30 p.m. last night, and I’d slugged it back with about three or four gulps of a locally brewed cough medicine --- an elixir from Lahore called Pulmonol Syrup sporting a drawing of two congested lungs on its label. When I woke up in a coughing fit at 3:20 this morning in my cold hole-in-the-wall room at Khani’s Hotel, I found myself in full stupor.

            Stumbling around and confused.

            Coughing like a madman and inexplicably angry.

            Infected by the squalid mood of some remote nightmare I’d had while I was still asleep and couldn’t remember now.

            A horrible mood.

            As un-settling bad in the middle of the night as it had been surprisingly good last night. When I’d passed out smiling about that obnoxious wall of Peshawar street noise, pondering the obtuse pleasure I’d experienced while watching the air war as the terrorists at Tora Bora got bombed to smithereens.

            And then I woke up at 3:20 this morning feeling as though I’d been hit by a fucking Cruise Missile.

            Stumbling into the unheated bathroom coughing and slugging back a couple more gulps of the cough medicine. Stumbling back to bed feeling like a bad drunk --- in a drowsy, depressed, and fuzzy near-consciousness.

            Was it the fog of war?

            Or was it the fatigue of this jet lag and flu that wouldn’t ever quit?

            Or was it the funking effects of the cures that spun my head around and gave me the shakes and the bed-spins?

            I slowly regained my senses over time, and the spinning and shaking nearly stopped after awhile. So I sorted out what I knew and what still perplexed me.

            What I knew was that I was in an unheated third-floor walkup, cigarette-burns-in-the-carpet/cold-water box at Khani’s Hotel in Saddar Bazaar in Taliban-infested Peshawar, Pakistan.

            What still perplexed me was everything else.

            I’d just gotten past that fact when I suddenly made out the roar of the B-52 bombers. I was still confused and groggy, and couldn’t really open up my eyes yet, but it sounded like the roar went on nonstop for the 15 or 20 minutes it took for me to jump-start my brain.

            The last couple of nights I’d hear the warplanes at what I found to be a predictable pace,  a B-52 (or a wave of them?) roaring directly over my head about once every 20 minutes or so. But sitting there in my stupor on the bed for that 15 or 20 minutes, it seemed like the roar went on forever at full volume without ever taking a break. Perhaps it did --- --- --- I sat there perplexed, trying to focus on consciousness, but pondering bombers instead.

            It had really been quite an air war so far. For the coalition here and now. For the terrorists in the opening attacks of the war on the American front in New York, Washington, and Pennsylvania. Using civilian jets as jet fuel bombs. Then came the response bombing of Afghanistan beginning on Oct. 7 eventually leading to the deaths of many more civilians and the liberation of much of Afghanistan and the ouster of the Taliban from Kabul on Nov. 13 and then from Kandahar last week.

            By the time the roar of the latest bomber or bombers had passed over me and was trailing off in the distance, the new cough medicine began to work and I gathered enough strength to stumble over to the television set to turn it on so I could catch up with the war through my CNN Breaking News Box. As I sat back on the bed --- too woozy to lay back down too quickly for fear of passing out from the head rush I’d gotten on the way back from locating the CNN channel on the remote-control-less 13-inch antique color television set --- I heard the cranking back up of a new wave of bombers. Coming close enough over me for its rumble (when at its loudest) to shiver the water in the glass on the lamp table next to my bed. Over Peshawar and me on their way up the Grand Trunk Road over the Khyber Pass to deliver their loads of bombs to their Tora Bora drop zones.

            The sound of the bombers got louder and louder, the way jets get when they’re flying overhead and coming toward you. Louder and louder with the rumble getting more throaty as it came. And soon I could no longer quite hear the CNN Breaking News Box reports without straining my already blurred concentration. Something from the talking head on the box about B-52 bombers pummeling the Tora Bora cave complex in the White Mountains of Afghanistan at this hour --- the CNN director using videotape made this afternoon while I was over the Khyber Pass, of B-52 bomber trails streaking across the sky --- made by some TV cameraman from somewhere on the outskirts of the battle.

            But aside from still being groggy (and now not being able to hear what the TV was trying to tell me) I realized I had a headache as well. Still in that inexplicable bad mood. Still trying to figure out the smarmy bad dream that took me from sky high on Friday evening to under the boot this morning. And now a headache as well.

            But then as I slugged back a couple of aspirin tablets (chasing them down with another gulp of Pulmonol cough syrup,) it dawned on me what may have happened to my mood. I wished I was strong enough to get up off the bed to turn up the sound on the CNN Breaking News Box without passing out so I could hear more about what they were trying to tell me about the bombing that was happening just up the road, over the roar of the bombers flying over my bed that they were trying to report to me about. But I just couldn’t get up to turn up the volume on the TV --- and now, relieved of some of my confusion, I couldn’t turn down the noise of the bombers in my head either.

            The bombers!

            It was the blasted bombers and all the negative connotations bombers have always had for me throughout my lifetime that turned my mood sour. It wasn’t a nightmare or a medicine hangover. It was the noise of the goddamn bombers overtaking the noise of holiday Ed-al-Fitr celebrations and the racquet of the Peshawar streets that turned my mood and woke me up and put me in this stupor. Sure, the medication hangover and the shock of enjoying the bombing so much yesterday may have been contributing factors. But it was probably the noise of the bombers and of a Being There overdose that was too much for my subconscious to take. It probably made me think in my sleep about the American Coalition response and about my lifelong opposition to war and about September 11 and about how my support of the American Coalition self-defense response had made me put all that away for a while. Made me send my pacifism on a sabbatical and reluctantly embrace the last resort of all-out war.

            A warp of my belief system I probably hadn’t had time to deal with up until now. A reaction to the relaxation of my ideals and a suppression of my sense of forgiveness and charity, perhaps. All in the name of an instinctive and compulsory self-defense.

 

~

 

                        After awhile the bombers roared away into the night and the sound of them trailed off like airplane sounds do in the night when aircraft are flying steadily away from you --- getting quieter and less pronounced as they went. And again (before the roar of one wave faded and the roar of another wave overwhelmed)  I could hear what the talking heads were saying on the CNN Breaking News Box. They were going to a commercial break at that point but they were saying they’d be right back to tell me the latest afternoon (in Atlanta) news from Tora Bora and the Afghan War front. Just as that new wave of bomber noise became audible above the commercial on the TV set and the last few taxi cab horns of an extraordinary Ramadan Friday night faded down the Peshawar streets somewhere outside my window. And in a fit of moaning adequacy, I recovered myself just enough to get up on my feet, and I shuffled over to the TV to turn up the volume over the roar of the new wave of bombers.

            I had to know what the latest details were, all I knew now was the disturbing noise of all those damn B-52 bombers ...

            And as the noise of the next bombing run climaxed, the CNN Breaking News Box filled with advertisements for new cars and new TV shows and then afterward cut to a dusty brown camera view of Friday’s action at the Tora Bora battlefield front lines. Videotapes showing clouds of smoke and debris from bombs dropped by B-52 and B-1 bombers and coalition fighter jets, rising in the valley and clouding up the ridges of the White Mountains. Videotape that forced me to ponder the whole strange trial of life.

            I tried to keep up, as incapacitated as I was, with what they were telling me up on the television set. News reports about Friday afternoon air attacks on cave complexes by AC-130 attack planes and fighter jets and B-52 and B-1 bombers and live nighttime reports about, “fierce night bombing runs mercilessly dropping bombs on the Afghan White Mountains.” Reports about Pakistani soldiers deployed along the border, purportedly blocking the Coalition enemy’s escape and purportedly hunting down fleeing Taliban and al-Qaida to capture or kill. TV reports about hazardous mountain roads and about warplanes flying all about overhead, carrying bombs into the battlefield or returning from bombing runs to pick up more weapons.

            In and out and in and out and in and out of Tora Bora ...

 

 

 

~

December 15, 2001

 
Yesterday’s News

 

 

“Revenge is a Dish Which Tastes Better Cold.”

                          an ancient Pashtun saying

 

 

*WTC North Wall of North Tower Pulled Down Today

 

                The news I heard today made sense.
   September 11 put us into shock, threw us into action, put us at war, and yesterday at the Al-Qaida Last Stand we were finally put a little bit at ease. Several thousand people had been killed at Ground Zero (the official number still isn’t in yet), and it all started when a jetliner was rammed into the north wall of the north tower of the World Trade Center at 8:46 a.m. (ET) on the morning of September 11. Where the president of the United States stood amid the smoking ruins a couple days later and assured the rescue workers and the terrorists alike that the whole civilized world would be coming after them now.

 

 

   NYC GZ WTC Wreckage 1.jpg (189719 bytes)  

   

Headline News*[5]

Continual Bombing Runs Over Tora Bora on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

                * Those promises fulfilled and those lives avenged this weekend by the American-led anti-terror Coalition. And so (although it was probably coincidental) it was fitting that today was the day that civilian recovery workers at Ground Zero chose to pull down that haunting ten-story stub. The relic I described in my journal last month as, “Just standing there mangled and grim. Mocking our weakness against the anarchy of evil that hit us out of the blue and provided everyone alive its best evidence of the horror that overtook us that day. A broken icon sticking horribly up through the nearly flattened mess --- poking jaggedly up from the rubble under the hole in the skyline like a spook. A grotesque sight. Looking like the end of the world ...”
 

                 And time shall eventually heal all wounds, and time will eventually lead us back to peace. But for now we still had to finish what we started ...

 

                * Afghan fighters and American forces scouted mountains Saturday to root out Osama bin Laden loyalists, reporting gains against al-Qaida positions but finding no fresh evidence they were closing in on its leader. Steady US air strikes and pressure by ground forces appeared to be scattering Osama bin Laden fighters across the rocky and forested mountains today as they attempt to surrender, hide, or escape. Reports of impromptu surrender negotiations, mule-back escapes and isolated sniper fire created a picture Saturday of a defending force in its final throes...little resistance left, only small arms fire, The culminating major operation of the 10-week-long US/Coalition military campaign in Afghanistan.

 

             * Saturday’s fighting played out amid a swirl of information, talk of surrender deals that didn’t materialize, and prisoners who may or may not have been taken. Much of the information was simply contradictory --- and impossible to verify on a day when Afghan commanders refused to allow reporters to visit the front lines. The bombings were largely concentrated on a single ridgeline on Friday, but were spread out over a larger area on Saturday.

 

 

  

 

 *Peshawar to Islamabad:      
  
Tough Shooting    

 

 

Descendants of Adam!

 

We have sent you clothing

To hide your shame and to adorn you;

                                                                                                                                                               

Descendants of Adam,

Wear your adornments

At every place of worship,

And eat and Drink:

But do not be extravagant,

For God does not love those who waste.

 

                                                                                the Quran

 

 

                        Trying to do what I like to do with my camera here (in the chaotic condition this region is in right now) is extremely difficult and exhausting. All regular photographers here are under the boot of an array of overbearing religious, governmental, wartime, and tribal photo rules and customs suppressive to my streetphoto mission.

            Because of added security measures on Friday (due to the magnitude of the Tora Bora events) I couldn’t even use my camera for a few hours and when I went out on the streets (whether in Rawalpindi, Islamabad, Peshawar --- or especially in the Afghan refugee camps on that red line border on the CNN Breaking News Box War Map) I was suppressed by a variety of military and cultural issues that cramped my style.

            I’d heard several reliable stories about local men pummeling foreign photographers for taking pictures of their wives, mothers, or sisters. Rocks being slammed into cameras and onto the heads of culturally insensitive journalists.

            And even when I got away with using women as supporting street elements, they almost all dressed alike. Veiled in conservative loose-fitting garments right out of the Old Testament, usually colored in desert earth tones or black. Clothing without a bit of sex appeal to them (for a Westerner’s taste). Only bold in their flowing manner. And only stimulating in our Western view of this clothing as an indicator of the domination and suppression of women here by men.

            But the men too also mostly dressed themselves in dull-colored loose-fitting outfits designed to camouflage the shape of their bodies (to avoid sexual temptations) and to keep them comfortable and protected in the barren extreme world they lived in. Clothing that was mostly uninspiring and which did nothing for the strengths of color film. The street vendors and the bustling market bazaar alleys themselves were exceedingly colorful and interesting, but the vendors were almost always dull-colored, too-camera aware, and too weary of my motives to capture candidly.

 

            During my entire trip, the sky was so perpetually shrouded in the dank, hazy, and polluted fog of this southeast-central Asian atmosphere, that it made contrast difficult, thereby making use of black and white film mushy. Although the dank pall (when I could squeeze enough contrast out of the workable light for a workable shot) could be exploited to paint the gloom of the mood of the turmoil into an occasional striking image --- but overall, the gloomy atmosphere made for fair-to-lousy exposures. The unattractive light too-often leaking potentially good moments into the haze of how I’d liked to have captured them.

            I couldn’t count the number of times I framed a photo, just to dismiss it without even trying because I knew the picture either wouldn’t be visually bold enough or intellectually stimulating enough (due to the dark pall) to satisfy my sense of what a good streetphoto should bring to the game.

 

            Several policemen made me stop taking pictures in Peshawar and eight or nine older men there confronted me and made me stop taking pictures on their blocks. The army and the tribal escorts said no pictures with no humor, and left little room at the wrong end of a gun to manipulate them into changing their minds. The culture said no to taking pictures of women, no to taking pictures of religion as an interpretive subject, no to taking pictures of military sites, airports, or bridges, and sometimes no just for being an American with the nerve to wander their streets alone and point my goddamn Western eye at them in the hour of their defeat.

            The Kalashnikov zealots said no with a spit on the ground and with hateful and intimidating sneers and with the absolute rejection of my little American streetphoto mission burning in their cold dark eyes.

           

            I was trailed by beggars and giggling children wherever I went, all treating me like a freak and getting in the way of the candid streetphoto moments I find most compelling. Giving me only seconds to study a place before crowds would descend on me --- distracting me and spoiling my view. Having to avoid spending too much time on any one street at any one time before getting hassled by the street lord or Taliban sympathizers or by a cop or a soldier. Or having to avoid getting sucked into another dammed-if-you-do/ damned-if-you-don’t American policy tea party.

            So the only tactic that made sense after awhile for me was to just keep moving slowly forward, nod and smile a lot, and occasionally stop and chat with someone who compelled me to do so despite my reservations. Coming back to places I noticed as good background material and working the location for a few minutes, one undisturbed minute-long pass at a time over several days.

            I’d go from shop to shop, vendor to vendor, pedestrian to pedestrian, with my eyes only stopping to shoot and then taking the chance for only one or two shots before the gawking crowd would invariably fill in the scene and ruin the spontaneity.

            Many would plead with me to take their picture: Take my picture! Take my picture! Take my picture! Sometimes even insisting I take their picture before they’d let me continue along my way. And so when that occurred I’d usually take one or two shots of them just to please them, turning down their offer of a bench and some tea more often then not. And then I’d move on up the teeming exotic alleys smiling and nodding as I went. My eyes flashing from hardware stores, to Eid (the end of Ramadan celebration) trinket vendors, to thickening crowds, to tailor shops, to fruit and vegetable stands. Always spending more than a third of my time glancing backward, watching the rear for danger and keeping track of my location on the street map in my head in case I ever needed to make a hasty retreat for one reason or another to a locked door.

            Although I was spending an average of about seven grueling hours a day (weakened by my flu and the jet-lag) shooting out on the streets, the effect of all the poor conditions and suppressive rules and customs combined to give me only quarter-time effect in the camera. The seven hours (minus all the hassles) worked out (I figure) to less than two hours of effective street photography on, say --- the streets of San Francisco. And when I’m out working the streets of San Francisco or Toronto or Amsterdam (which hold no intimidation for me and little threat of arrest, being stoned bloody, or being kidnapped, killed, or worse) I get to spend up to 10 effective hours a day wandering around.

            It was exhausting and far more dangerous in Saddar Bazaar in Peshawar than in the edgy but comparatively civilized Aabpara Market in Islamabad. But the whole circus tired me out wherever I went and while I’d managed between tea sessions, Kalashnikov spits, tribal delays, access issues, and the parade of gawkers to collect the candid slice of market street life I came here for during this worldwide war against terror, the whole thing wore me out.

 

~

 

                        I laid back on the bed in my Peshawar room at Khani’s Hotel this morning thinking that it was probably time to start heeding the whispers I’d been hearing from people out on the street the past two days. To either get out of town or to watch myself more carefully than I’d been watching myself the past few days, “Because you know --- you’re not very safe here right now.”

            I began thinking that after Thursday and Friday, my job here was done, and that perhaps it was probably time to admit that in my vulnerable condition I’d perhaps already overstayed my welcome and should get out of town. And so I decided that I’d just go back down the Grand Trunk Road to my base camp room in Islamabad tomorrow and take a week off from the exhausting streetphoto circus and concentrate on writing the journal and losing this flu instead. Cloister myself for a break from the overwhelming adulation, distrust, disgust, suppression, hate, and fear inside my CNN-Breaking-News-Box equipped, cigarette-burns-in-the-carpet, 500-rupees-a-night, cold-water flat in Islamabad.

            I went out into the Peshawar bazaar to buy another bottle of Pulmonal cough medicine and some food and supplies for a day-long writing session and to get one last good Osama bin Laden tribute T-shirt vendor streetphoto for the project. And afterward on my way back upstairs, the hotel clerk nervously stopped me and he asked me if I could please pay him in advance for my room, “As Eid is upon us.” He also delivered a message to me from my cabby who I’d made a deal with on Wednesday to take me back to Islamabad on Sunday. The note said, “1000 rupees not enough to drive on Eid eve.”

            The scoundrel was re-negotiating the deal, and my ride back to Islamabad before commerce shut down for the holiday. And then the raggedy gunman at the door told me I’d be, “lucky to get a cab for Islamabad today for under 3000 rupees, so maybe you should just stay here for Eid and go back after the holiday, eh?

            It was at that time that I began becoming concerned for my safety and decided that rather than just stay in my room here being sick and writing for three days where I’m a predictable lone vulnerable American target --- a fly on the wall at the edge of tribal law and well known (after five days) to be in town alone over at Khani’s --- that I’d follow my instinct (that I’d pushed this thing as far as I could go with it) and head back to the comfort of marshal law in Islamabad instead. No matter what the cab ride costs. And as I was standing there making that decision while paying the clerk, I noticed that all the men who hang out in the lobby all seemed nervous today. I’d gotten those several unspecific whispered warnings the past 36 hours from the streets which were easy to ignore, because they were unspecific and I already knew it was dangerous for me to be here. But now the hotel clerk’s eyes had suddenly gotten shifty as he inexplicably asked me to pay cash up front, “As Eid is upon us,” and who looked nerve-wracked as he hadn’t looked during my contact with him in the days before. The cabby had canceled our pre-negotiated Sunday run to Islamabad and the gunman at the door thought I should, “Just stay here for Eid and go back after the holiday ”(on Tuesday).

            I only found circumstances closing in on me a few times up to that point on this streetphoto expedition. It was nerve-wracking just getting off the airplane in Islamabad. But that turned out fine. The Taliban sympathizers menacing me in the Peshawar alley on Thursday night was extremely edgy for a couple of minutes. As it was edgy yesterday when I got caught out and hemmed in for a couple of minutes during Friday late-morning street prayers in Saddar Bazaar.

            Smuggling myself into the camps disguised as an Afghan and giving that human rights speech there was a little scary, and realizing we were a hot spot on that Afghan road on the Khyber Pass yesterday was creepy. And staying too long in Peshawar by myself (after several whispered warnings and after confronting the shifty set of circumstances in the lobby of the hotel this morning) had now been elevated to that list.

            So I paid the man for the four nights, and I went upstairs and quickly packed the few things I’d brought with me from Islamabad or that I bought in Peshawar and in three or four minutes time I was back out on the street flagging down a cabby who agreed to immediately take me the 170 kilometers back down the Grand Trunk Road to my base camp in Islamabad for 1300 rupees, or about $20 US.

            On the way back to Islamabad I didn’t take a single picture. I was at the natural end of my inspiration with the camera here --- my form of street photography difficult to cope with here on top of the never-ending jet lag and the fierce head cold and flu, and that dusty cough that wouldn’t go away and which won’t let me sleep more than a couple of hours at a time. On the way back to Islamabad the cabby even stopped at a rest stop among a group of brightly clad Sikh who begged me to photograph them in their outstanding red outfits. But I just stood there limp and finished and watched them giggle at me, waving at me and saying the only English they knew to me over and over again:

            Hello, how are you?

            Hello, how are you?

            Hello, how are you?

            I was exhausted, I was sick, and my bum left leg had begun throbbing in pain at a teeth-gnashing intensity it only attains once or twice a year --- a symptom of all that walking.

 

            I was done.

 

            So I vowed during the rest of that taxicab ride back to Islamabad at the end of my streetphoto energy, that except for perhaps spending some time with Shahid and his family during Eid or re-supplying myself at the market with food, drink, cigarettes, and maybe a couple of space heaters --- that until at least next Sunday, I’d just hole up in my room at the New Islamabad Hotel and alternately sleep, recover, watch the CNN Breaking News Box, eat, smoke, and write.

            I figured by then it would only be a few days before Christmas and by then I’d again feel up to exposing myself to the danger and adulation of these fascinating streets.

 

 

*Catching a Break

 

 

                        I got back to my base camp at the New Islamabad and the Muslim staff (a lot more cheerful and more accommodating to me now that I’m familiar to them) was busy erecting and decorating a Christmas tree. And because the only ticket I could get out of here when I made my reservations in October was for after Christmas, I was glad the hotel was going to have a Christmas spirit.

            I settled back into my old room. I unpacked the toilet paper and a towel, and I took an overdue five-day streetphoto shower. A (cold-water) comfort that I had no time for while up on the red line border (or that I just couldn’t summon up enough courage to try in the scary shower setup at Khani’s). I’d just gotten dry and settled back down on the bed in front of the CNN TV News Box, gratefully contemplating my coming isolation here when my phone rang. It startled me because last time I was here the phones didn’t work. I picked up the receiver and it was my travel agent.

            She had good news.

            She was glad I was there, she said, because someone had just canceled their ticket on tonight’s weekly flight out to New York and that a friend of hers at the airline offered the seat to her to offer to me. I’d have to be ready to meet the 3:30 a.m. flight in a matter of hours, and I’d miss mastering those few extra shots I wanted to get next week when I was well that I hadn’t tried or mastered yet for my World War III streetphoto essay. But If I left tonight I figured I’d not only get back in time for the holiday, but if I got lucky switching my connection in New York, I might even get home in time for Janet’s birthday on Tuesday.

            The deal was clinched when my travel agent told me that the canceled seat was a business class seat instead of coach, but that the airline was letting me switch even-up.

            Let’s see... either hole up for a week, sick, exhausted, and emotionally and artistically finished in this cold box --- and then emerge as a Christmas orphan in the middle of Pakistan (actually, the most inviting part of the choice), or bug out in first-class comfort for the more-than-day-long airline trip because I’d already accomplished what I came here for and because I’d be home for the holidays ...

 

            It wasn’t even close!

 

            And so at 10 p.m. I had the hotel clerk call a cab to the airport --- and just like that I was headed home for Christmas.

 
* Go to Chapter SIX

 NEXT Chapter              Table of Contents              History Index              Home

 

[1] CNN

[2] Associated Press

[3] See Asia Front sources on the Source Page at back of book

[4] See Asia Front sources on the Source Page at back of book

[5] See Asia Front sources on the Source Page at back of book